Race in America Critique - 1041 Words

Dr. Engel ENG 201-06 24 February 2014 â€Å"Race in America: ‘We Would Like to Believe We Are Over the Problem’† Critique In her piece for the Catholic weekly publication America, â€Å"Race in America: ‘We Would Like to Believe We Are Over the Problem’,† Maryann Cusimano Love responds to a comment made by Delegate Frank D. Hargrove Sr. and discusses the still prevalent issue of racism in the United States of America. Love provides many facts and figures in obstruction to Delegate Hargrove’s belief that the blacks in America need to move past the grudge of slavery because it is not an issue today. Love obviously disagrees with his statement and spends the majority of the article arguing why he is wrong, as well as providing her solution to the†¦show more content†¦The connection between these two topics is vague and the lines of logic that are assumed connect the two are left unexplained. Love’s balance of the different ideas of her thesis is uneven, making s ome aspects of it ineffective. She spends the majority of the article stating facts and figures that she believes support her argument. The solution she gives is short, shallow, and is summed up in one sentence. It sounds as though Love is not as concerned with providing a key to peace as she is with bringing to attention to â€Å"unfairness† of certain parts of American society. Again, the meat of her writing is intended to manipulate the emotions and cloud the reasoning of readers. Although Love brings many pieces of evidence to the forefront in an attempt to show the racism that still exists in the United States of America, she does so shallowly and manipulatively in order to support her weak and poorly developed argument. I agree with Love in her opinion that racism is still an issue in our country today, but not for the reasons she provides. I believe that had she used fewer statistics, had cited those statistics more, and had relied more on a solution to this problem, i t would have been a more convincing stance. Also, her deceptive interpretation of Delegate Hargrove’s statements was completely off - putting for me. Yes, I think that hisShow MoreRelatedJudgement In Catfish Mandala By Andrew X. Pham1188 Words   |  5 PagesAppearance is Everything Judgement is the ability to make any decision or conclusion commonly about a person, or its actions. It includes two types: constructive and destructive critiques. Most of the time positive opinions contribute toward the self-ideas of getting better. On the other hand, destructive opinions affect the person negatively in a specific way. As humans, we do many things without noticing them. Judgement is one of them. It is a part of daily life. The book Catfish Mandala, byRead MoreThe Twentieth Century1583 Words   |  7 Pagesbecause of the roles that it played in making the United States the way that it is today. Race was also a factor in how changes were made to our laws, the events that transpired throughout those 100 years, and the way that people were treated. Race has been an issue throughout our nation’s history that we cannot deny and is still an issue in today’s society. The book Superfluous Men is a book filled with many critiques of how the American society w as ran and the events that were happening during that timeRead MoreGranting The Rights Of African Americans : Reconstruction Period1519 Words   |  7 Pagesprotection of private property and the opportunity to run for elected office. However by the year 1910, African Americans could no longer claim many of these rights. At the close of the nineteenth century and the beginning of the twentieth century, race relations between the whites and the blacks also underwent many changes and it changed for the worse and finally it paved way for mass movement for Civil Rights. D Augustus Straker, in The New South Investigated (1988) mentions the concept of a NewRead MoreThe Death Of Trayvon Martin1723 Words   |  7 Pagessocioeconomic issues related to race, matters of representation – and it seemed to him that â€Å"liberal† culture, in these voices and through the media, was making us racist. The fact that race was being treated as an element at play in public action, to him, denied the ideals of equality that ought to have motivated the American ideology, that somehow it denied us a necessary recognition that the Civil Rights Movement had accomplished its work, and that now in America, all God’s children can be freeRead MoreRacially Based Jury Nullification : Black Power Essay1026 Words   |  5 PagesRacially Based Jury Nullification: Black Power in the Criminal Justice system was written in December, 1995 in a Yale Law Journal by Paul Butler, and then later republished in 2015 in Introduction to Legal Studies. This article was published in North America, for academics in the law stream, or anyone with an interest in law. The author poses different views on the racism in todays court rooms faced by African Americans. In this essay, I will examine the article in detail to determine whether or not theRead MoreAnalysis Of Flaming Iguanas By Cormac Mccarthy1085 Words   |  5 PagesTransfiguration of America Through Road Novels Flaming Iguanas by Erika Lopez and The Road by Cormac McCarthy critiques America, while transgressing heteronormativity and modifying mobility and identity. Traveling west is an adventure and an opportunity to discover oneself, it is also an extension to exercise one s freedom. As a woman,Tomato Rodriguez travels across the country to see his dad in California. Being on the road transgresses the meaning of the road, whilst inventing one’s identityRead MoreLiberation Theology Essay1157 Words   |  5 PagesIntroduction According to Enns (2008), liberation theology attempts to infer the holy writ through the plight of the poor. This movement originated from South America in the early 1950s when Marxism was the most popular theory among the poor. It was a response to the ill-treatment and poverty facing the ordinary people. It dealt with the issue of distribution of wealth among people in order to upgrade the economic status in life. This movement had strong Romanian Catholic roots bolstered in ColombiaRead MoreAnalysis Of Cornel West s Race Matters1205 Words   |  5 PagesIn Cornel West’s â€Å"Race Matters†, he expresses his thoughts and ideas on a variety of different issues we have encountered in both past and present times. One such issue is the failure of the liberal structuralist program. West introduces the Nihilistic threat to the readers, where life is meaningless and purposeless to the universe, and then explains how liberal structuralists seemingly fail to deal with this threat. He begins by blaming the liberal structuralists for focusing too heavily on theRead MoreThe Cultural Identity Of The African American Community1653 Words   |  7 PagesAmerican community has sat at the end of a discriminatory lens from the moment they set foot in the United States. For that reason, black communities have undergone the process of community building to ensure that all members feel a sense of belonging. Race, gender, nationality, ethnicity, poverty, and sexual orientation, all play a role in developing one’s identity and more often than not, these multiple identities intersect with blackness. Being that American society has deemed colored people and populationsRead MoreThe Castle Of My Skin994 Words   |  4 Pages As such, it is impossible for a critique of the novel to address its multifaceted nature, even when dealing with a single theme. In practice, this effectively deconstructs the traditional form of identity within the village in which it is set, while being part of an intellectual movement in Caribbean literature and culture of constructing an identity centered on race, and the unity of historical hardships facing all individuals of African descent in the Americas. Lamming consistently emphasizes